International Council Correspondence · Vol. II, no. 12 · November 1936
Max Nomad’s answer[1] to our article “Dictatorship of the Intellectuals?” (C.C., No. 7) gives us occasion to take up the theme once more. All considered, however, there is not much additional that needs to be said; now as before, the two conceptions stand fundamentally opposed. The space still available to us in this debate is to be used merely for refuting a few objections which seem to us unjustified and for clearing up various points which appear to have been left obscure.
Nomad objects to our borrowing the phrase about the “dictatorship of the traveling salesmen” (16) from a certain Jerome, a salaried employee of the C.P. We are not interested in Jerome or his connections; and while this particular statement of his appeared to us to hit the mark, we by no means identify ourselves with its author, any more than we identify ourselves with Nomad when we quote him with approval. The excitement about Jerome we leave confidently to Nomad himself, who no doubt characterizes this fellow correctly. To us, all the present functionaries and “leaders” of the old labor movement are in the last analysis “Jeromes”, with whom we have nothing to do but with whom we are often obliged, nevertheless, to concern ourselves. Since these fellows do a lot of talking, they also frequently say something that strikes us as accurate; and in such a case it appears that Nomad also is not averse to turning the thing to account. For example, in his argument against us (27), he appeals to K.A. Wittfogel, who likewise is of the camp of the Third International, and to Heinz Neumann, a salaried subject of the C.P. and one of the lowest scoundrels with which the labor movement has ever been burdened. Nomad may still explain to us why he himself is to be permitted to “borrow from a source from which ordinary prudence should have told us to keep away”. (16)
Nomad wishes (16) to “protest specifically against one particular instance of our polemic methods, dealing not with matters of opinion or interpretation but with actual facts.” “P.M.”, he says, “declares as ‘groundless’ the ‘whole story’ that Bismarck in pursuance of his state socialist (or state capitalist) plans, had solicited the support of Marx and of his closest associates. In the first place, I did not claim, as P.M. seems to insinuate, that this was ‘a proof of the compatibility of Marxism with state capitalism’. In an article dealing with State Socialism and State Capitalism, this was adduced as evidence of Bismarck’s state socialist tendencies. In the second place, my ‘groundless’ assertion is based upon a full-length story by Wilhelm Liebknecht, one of Marx’s closest associates, told in his Kein Kompromiss, kein Wahlbundnis (page 8) which, in condensed form, I had presented in my Marx biography published in Scribner’s, March 1933, page 190.”
In Scribner’s, for June 1934, page 409, Nomad wrote: “At the close of the sixties, Bismarck played with the idea of nationalizing all branches of Germany’s economic life. To carry out that plan, he even solicited the collaboration of Marx and his closest associates.” On page 410, Nomad continues: “The reason for the German Socialist’s opposition to the State Socialism (i.e. State Capitalism) of the Prussian Junkers was obvious. Under the political overlordship of the Hugenbergs and Von Papens of those years, all the power, all the more privileged positions in the government, in the administration of the Nation’s economic and political life, would go to the educated scions of the Junkers and the upper middle classes, while the educated lower middle classes, from which most of the Socialist leadership issued, would be reduced to the role of mere subalterns with salaries of low-paid white-collar slaves. That is why in his time, Karl Marx, as a revolutionary democrat, disregarded Bismarck’s offer, and why the Socialists, as a general rule, have not been enthusiastic about the nationalization of individual branches of industry in those countries which lacked democratic institutions.” (Emphasis ours.)
To which we replied in C.C. #7, page 21: “Nomad mentions the state-capitalist plans of Bismarck and states that Bismarck sought to assure himself of Marx’s aid in the matter. But this can hardly be alleged as proof of the compatibility of Marxism with state capitalism, even supposing that Bismarck had actually entered into such relations with Marx. As a matter of fact, the whole story is groundless; Bismarck never turned to Marx in this connection, but conducted an inconsequential correspondence with Lassalle, whose opportunism, as is well known, always met with Marx’s severest condemnation.”
Any unprejudiced reader on comparing these two quotations can see for himself that Nomad’s protestation is in vain. His entire article in Scribner’s is concerned with pointing out that the marxist as well as the fascist movement is driving to state capitalism; every example of which he there makes use serves to support this thesis, hence also the alleged intermezzo between Marx and Bismarck. Since he furthermore presents the reason by which Marx was led to reject Bismarck’s offer namely, because there was not enough in it for the socialist intellectuals, nothing further is needed to demonstrate that Nomad sees here also the compatibility of Marxism with state capitalism. For Marx rejected the offer, according to Nomad, solely and exclusively because the reward was too slight; from which the only natural inference is that there would possibly have been no refusal if Bismarck had offered more than… “salaries of low-paid white-collar slaves.”
Nomad appeals to the authority of W. Liebknecht in order to show that his story in Scribner’s was not ‘groundless’. He appeals, that is, to the authority of a man of whom he himself has said: “For though he had been in personal touch with Marx. . . what is usually called ‘scientific socialism’ had always remained the deepest secret to him. A master of ultra-revolutionary oratory today, and of ultra-moderate and opportunist journalism tomorrow, and at bottom nothing but a radical democrat. For the father of the immortal German rebel of 1918 lacked both tact and consistency, and his only redeeming feature was his dog-like devotion to Marx, even tho the latter treated him like a dog”, (“Johann Most”, Modern Monthly, July 1936, page 15.) It is upon a propaganda pamphlet of this man, who, like Nomad, had a special predilection for trumpeting the state capitalist plans of Bismarck, for making mysterious plots out of the capitalistic “labor policy” of the time and for “showing up” the “duplicity” of the government in an equally “duplicitous” and mysterious manner,—it is upon the chatter of this man that Nomad tries to support his assertions in Scribner’s. It is true that Liebknecht has frequently related (e.g., apart from the passages drawn upon by Nomad, also in the Leipzig trial for high treason in 1872, that the prussian government and the prussian junkers had made the most persistent attempts to induce him to exploit the labor movement in their own interest, and that after he had become certain of the matter, he had “broken off all connections with the agents and hired writers of Herr Bismarck”; but these unproved, exaggerated and frequently also well-founded turns of speech on the part of Liebknecht (for no doubt at that time, just as today, attempts were made to secure the labor leaders for political purposes) can by no means be used to construe the possibility of a connection between Bismarck and Marx.
In reality, the “state-capitalist” plans of Bismarck consisted in nothing more than various political manoeuvers for securing the interests of the government, which never had any intention of serving more than Germany’s upswing along the path of private economy. We have already, in our article in C.C. #7, mentioned the reasons for the appearance of “state-capitalist” tendencies in otherwise “normal” capitalist countries. In Germany, the clash of capital and the struggle between aspiring capital and large landed property—a struggle which was later bridged over by way of compromises and Germany’s development into an imperialist power—had brought forth, by the side of many other political shufflings and manoeuvers, also the peculiar “labor policy” of Bismarck and the combination with Lassalle in the winter of 1863-64, and thereby a political atmosphere in which the entire working population frequently felt that it was the government’s darling. Lassalle was ready to support the Bismarck government in exchange for direct and universal suffrage. The “apostle of class harmony”, as he was called by J. Knief, hoped then to secure for himself a position in Parliament by means of which the situation of the workers was ostensibly to be improved. Hence his readiness to operate with the feudal reaction against Capital, his striving for the “social kingship” and a sort of Hitler-role for himself. Bismarck, however, turned down the proposition of introducing direct and universal suffrage and other concessions, such as workers’ cooperatives with financial aid of the State. All that had nothing to do with Marx and Marxism, a fact which even Nomad recognizes at another place.
Thus he writes in his biography of Most (Modern Monthly, June 1936, page 19): “With all his deadly criticism of capitalist profit-making, the author of Capital would have never considered the idea of allying himself with the feudal past as against the bourgeois present. But Lassalle, in order to further his own political ambitions, was flirting with Bismarck, and was ready to lend the Junkers the support of the working masses as against the Progressive Party, which represented the interest of the upper middle class”.[2]
Marx “would have never considered” because, as we learned from Nomad previously, he was not content “with salaries of low-paid white-collar slaves,” Lassalle, on the contrary, seemed to be more modest?
We have been compelled to take up Nomad’s “protest” in order to show that we are by no means interested, merely in order to win an argument, in twisting ideas or contesting facts. But after all, like the protest itself, so also our answer to it is so much wasted exertion; for regardless of whether Marx and Bismarck negotiated, wished to negotiate or were on the point of negotiating, or whether Bismarck asked or did not ask, whether Marx answered or failed to answer,–regardless of all that, we are sure that to Nomad state capitalism, or state socialism, remains identical with Marxism. Or doesn’t it?
We are glad to take note that Nomad has used the term intellectual to apply exclusively to “the vast crowd of educated or semi-educated people that may or may not have a college degree, but can make a livelihood without resorting to manual or lower clerical labor.” (17). And since at the same time it is essentially only the “outs”, not the “ins”, whom Nomad regards as having the state-capitalist ambitions, his preliminary material for the “Masters of Tomorrow” is limited to those intellectuals who are out of work or poorly paid. This infinitesimal minority of intellectuals, notwithstanding the fact that all the social instruments of power are in the hands of Capital and of the contented “ins”, succeeds in certain favorable situations in getting the masses behind it, in throwing out the capitalists and changing places with the “ins”. Whereupon the “ins” temporarily (as in Russia) become “outs”, and it is not until after the social wealth begins to increase and the possibility arises of conferring advantages upon all the intellectuals that the “outs” again become linked to the exploiting state apparatus. Thus Nomad summarizes his theory. Such, it appears, is the gist of Nomad’s theory. And so it is not the practicing, but the jobless or poorly paid intellectuals who are the champions of state socialism; they are such, then, not by reason of the fact that they are intellectuals, but because of their economic condition. Hence it is not essentially their intellectual function, which is either not exercised or poorly rewarded, but their political attitude and their gift of persuasion by which the masses are deluded, which forms the secret of their coming power. This is the conception which Nomad opposes to the marxist doctrine of class struggle. And while, moreover, in view of the great amount of unemployment among the workers, he casts doubt upon their capacity for self-rule based on control of the enterprises, the rule of the intellectuals depends precisely upon the unemployment and poverty existing among them. We shall come back to this point in the further course of these remarks. For the present, we might merely state that after this clarification of his intellectualist concept, Nomad’s theory strikes us as still more fantastic than before.
Nomad tries to demonstrate the existence of a contradiction in our position on the russian bureaucracy and the problem of the intellectuals. “On page 27”, he writes (19), “the bureaucrats are (to P.M.) the ‘capitalists’, and on page 17 they are the ‘intellectuals’,” To us, the russian state bureaucracy rates as a total capitalist. As a state bureaucracy, not as a group of intellectuals, it rules society and thus lives off society. We have not contested, but emphasized, that a large part of the intellectuals and of the intellectualized workers belongs to this bureaucracy. On page 17 we said: “The struggle of the workers against the intellectuals could practically be only a struggle against the labor bureaucracy or, as today in Russia, a struggle against a state bureaucracy. The struggle against the intellectuals in private-capitalist countries has meaning only so long as there is reformist activity and reformist organization…. It is not until and unless a state-capitalist revolution has been successful, it is only then that the struggle against the bureaucracy and hence against the intellectuals is taken up again….” And on page 27: “The special group of people which has the sole right of disposal over production is not the intellectuals but the state bureaucracy, which of course also embraces intellectuals.”
Since the labor bureaucracy, and later the state bureaucracy, consists in large part, or exclusively if preferred, of intellectuals, if the working class turns against the bureaucracy, its struggle is necessarily directed also against the intellectuals. But it does not combat the intellectuals just because they are intellectuals, any more than it combats stamp-collecting or art-loving capitalists as stamp collectors or art fanciers, but in both cases because they are exploiters. Intellectuals, however, cannot be exploiters unless they have control of the means of production. The working class cannot take a hostile position to the socially necessary intellectual professions brought into existence thru the social division of labor, but only to a deceitful labor bureaucracy or to an exploiting state apparatus, regardless of the social stratum there dominant. Of course it is possible to throw rotten eggs at a bad tenor belonging to Nomad’s intellectuals, but to mobilize the working class against him is surely something too much of a good thing. It would likewise be possible to attack the intellectual Nomad on the ground that he consumes bread which he himself has not baked and thus contributes to consuming the surplus value created by the workers; but that too would surely be carrying matters too far. Intellectuals are not capable of exploiting the workers merely because they are intellectuals. But: once they are in control of organizations, they can deceive the workers; and if they have at their disposal the means of production, they can exploit the workers. We repeat: insofar as the workers combat intellectuals, it can only be a struggle against the labor or state bureaucracy.
Our “very ingenuous argument”, as Nomad writes (18), by which the russian “intellectuals” are divided into intellectuals as such and into the state bureaucracy, so that the bureaucracy exploits that part of the intellectuals not belonging to it just as it does the workers-hence the fact that in this case we too, like Nomad himself, speak of “ins” and “outs”,—we are surprised to find that Nomad, whose whole theory is based on this twofold division of the intellectuals, now rejects it as improper. Insofar as concerns Russia, Nomad regards all the intellectuals as taking part in the exploitation of the workers, even though the shares of the booty turn out to be different in the different cases and the struggle for altering this relation still goes on. Nomad insists on the permanent revolution, that is, on the continuous struggle between the “ins” and “outs”. Well, then, he will have to admit that the success of the struggle between the “ins” and “outs” depends on a further factor. Why is it that the one group can draw more than the other? What are they fighting about? There is no doubt that they are fighting for positions of power, which are decisive in the distribution of the loot. Hence one group must have positions of power which the other does not. Hence the positions of power are not controlled by all the intellectuals, semi-intellectuals and ex-workers, but only by a part of them. With the denial of this fact, Nomad’s whole theory of the permanent struggle between the “ins” and “outs” collapses. With the acceptance of this fact, there likewise collapses the theory that all intellectuals are at the same time the exploiters. Nomad has thought himself into a blind alley. The plain fact is that the “ins” as a state bureaucracy control production and distribution; that is the source of their predominance with respect to the “outs”. These latter are confronted by the “ins” as master of the means of production, as capitalists, altho both the “ins” and the “outs” are here intellectuals.
With the aid of the dictionary and taking his stand on a russian phrase, Nomad regards all the intellectuals in Russia as state employees forming a part of the bureaucracy. We are not concerned either with the dictionary or with the russian phrase, but only with reality, and we are still waiting for Nomad to demonstrate that “the intellectuals as a whole, forming the state bureaucracy, are the masters of the country”, (20) If anyone were to say, with the russian bureaucrats themselves, that the state capitalism in Russia has put an end to the exploitation of the russian workers, Nomad would certainly give vent to all his scorn of such naivete. When the Bolsheviks assert, however, just as Hitler does of his National Socialism, that every laboring person in Russia is a part of the State and participates in the government, then Nomad accepts of this swindle exactly so much as he needs for his private theory and restricts his scorn to the part left over. He writes (19): “In Russia, where every branch of the country’s economic and cultural life is managed by the Government, every man who is not a peasant or manual worker is a government office-holder, a member of the bureaucracy.” As a matter of fact, the manual workers and peasants belong just as much (or just as little) to the state bureaucracy as does the great majority of the intellectuals, which works for the ruling bureaucracy just as the workers do. By reason of the class character of russian society and by reason of the different reproduction costs of labor power, the wages and salaries differ in the various occupations. The intellectuals are not better paid because they belong among the rulers, but because, in view of the fact that the market law continues to operate with reference to labor power, because wage labor still exists, the reproduction of labor power is not socially regulated but is left to the individuals. By the way, it ought to be known to Nomad that down until little over a year ago the russian state bureaucracy supported itself not so much upon the intellectuals as upon the skilled manual workers and was for this reason frequently dubbed a government of the “labor aristocracy”. It is not until quite recently that the picture seems to be changing and the bureaucracy seems to be adapting itself more to the interests of the intelligentsia and peasants, at the expense of the labor aristocracy as well as of the workers in general. This change of front is not a voluntary one; it corresponds to the inevitably increasing internal and external difficulties as well as to the general tendency to the strengthening of private interests in Russia. It is at the same time the old capitalist policy, which by means of economico-political manoeuvers weighs more or less heavily upon the different social groups at different times, so long as this is objectively possible, in order that actual control may remain in the hands of the government.
To support his idea that all intellectuals are to be rated as an exploiting bureaucracy, in spite of the contradictions among themselves, Nomad refers to the fact that in capitalist countries, in spite of the opposition between the small and large capitals, all capitalists are united by a common interest against the workers. In this connection, however, he neglects to note that the at present privileged russian intellectuals are not in a position to exercise direct exploitation, but have to be content with what is allowed them by the ruling bureaucracy. They have no power of disposal over the productive apparatus, whereas the small capitalists in the private-economy countries, however much they may be controlled by the large concerns, still, as immediate owners of means of production, are direct participants in the exploitation of the workers. It is right here, of course, that we have the difference between state- and private-ownership capitalism, a difference which Nomad carelessly overlooks when that is necessary for the defense of his theory.
Just as only a part of the intellectuals rises into the state bureaucracy, so it is only a still smaller part which sees matters in the way that Nomad conceives of them. What is Nomad’s proof that “ever growing sections of the more enlightened part of the intelligentsia in non-fascist Europe and America are flocking now to the various marxist parties”, that the “influence of the Communist Parties is now growing in France, Belgium, Spain, U.S.A., etc.” (21) Wherever the “marxist” (?) parties are growing today, they are growing not as independent movements on the march to power, to state socialism, but by reason of the fact that they no longer possess such ambitions, that they are restricting themselves to obtaining flunkey jobs to perform for private capital. That is quite well known to Nomad himself, as shown by the following passage (26): “If a large part of the intellectuals in various countries, instead of turning socialist or communist, joins the fascist ranks,…, it is their desire for a short cut to power that is responsible for the success of the new gospel. Many of the fascist intellectuals would join the communist movement if they saw that it had any chances, or at least intentions, of winning immediately. For by now it has become obvious to most observers that the leading Communists of the non-fascist countries have ceased to be revolutionaries at all; that ever since 1923 they have become ordinary Russian patriots abroad. Like the socialists of pre-War times, the Communists – meaning of course the official leadership — have become a party of anti-capitalist protest and not of anti-capitalist revolt.”
Hence, according to Nomad, the communist parties are growing because “ever growing sections of the more enlightened part of the intelligentsia. . . see in the Russian example the possibility of putting an end to their economic insecurity, the hope of throwing off the financial magnates, and the prospect of becoming masters of the country themselves,” (21) although it should, after all, be clear to this “more enlightened part of the intelligentsia” that “the leading communists have ceased to be revolutionaries at all”. According to Nomad, then, the C.P. is growing because it is state-capitalist and because it is not so, because it is striving for intellectualist rule and also because it is not; according to Nomad it constantly does what it ought to do in conformity with Nomad’s theories, even though in reality it does something quite different.
In countries which rate as backward from the point of view of objective ripeness for the proletarian revolution, the influence of the communist parties has recently increased as a result of the deepening of the crisis, while in those countries which have attained this objective ripeness, their influence has already sunk to something approaching zero, just because they did not seize the power, because they did not even strive for power; or because they simply did not pursue the plans which Nomad tries to ascribe to them. They simply refused to become the “Masters of Tomorrow”. That these elements, in the course of a proletarian revolution directed against them as well as against the bourgeoisie, will attempt to divert it into state capitalism does not affect the fact that they themselves are no longer doing anything for the success of a state-capitalist revolution. The intellectuals have now acquired a greater degree of interest in the C.P., just as they once did in the S.P., because it has ceased to pursue any state socialist plans and thereby improved its chances of becoming even today a legal mass-party with a lot of jobs to dispense. Even though individual intellectuals are taking up with state-capitalist dreams, still the growth of the communist parties is not determined by these illusionists, but by the petty vermin that wants to arrange itself somehow in the present-day world and wants to be something even today.
Fascism attracts the intellectuals because it takes an outspokenly small-capitalist position, because it wants to defend “creative” capital against the “financiers”, altho it is after all compelled to do the very opposite, simply because there is nothing else to be done. The circumstance that the fascist as well as the communist movement embraces people who dream of state capitalism does not affect the fact that the whole fascist movement has a pronouncedly private-capitalist orientation, even though it can nevertheless only subscribe to monopoly capital. Nomad’s calling up of the interesting bedtime story of the concealed designs of Mussolini to become the italian Lenin can hardly serve as proof of the “bolshevist” designs of the Fascists. Even before the founding of the fascist organizations, Mussolini had already sold himself to the italian capitalists. (Cf. A. Balabanoff’s “Als der Duce noch nicht Duce War”, Sozialistische Warte, March-April-May 1936; or, for that matter, Nomad’s biography of Mussolini in “Rebels and Renegades”.) Nomad may let himself be deluded by the capitalist tendencies to concentration and centralization, and wherever these tendencies operate, he may smell forthwith the state capitalism of the intellectuals; still this confusion of appearance with reality cannot affect the fact that these tendencies operate quite independently of the fascist or bolshevist parties and come forth quite as vigorously in countries without such parties as in those countries where they represent great mass movements.
In order to swell his material, Nomad is fond of throwing times and concepts together pell mell. Thus he writes on page 22 with reference to the capitalist war economy and the russian collectivization, conceiving both as conscious attempts at planning: “In both cases the economic interests of the acting classes involved was the driving force, which is what you call the human factor, and not the ‘objective’ or ‘extra-human’ element of the growth of the social forces of production.” In reality, however, these measures were imposed upon their “initiators” by the force of circumstances. Neither the war nor its economy, any more than the collectivization, was in conformity with the economic interests of the capitalists, or with those of the russian bureaucracy, as the case may be. War diminishes surplus value, the collectivization strengthens the forces directed against the bureaucracy; and yet the “initiators” of this economic policy are forced to take it up without regard to their own economic interests. Every exploiting society is subject to the contradiction that in safeguarding its immediate interests its further interests are extensively damaged; which is simply a manifestation of the power of the objective elements over the subjective.
In exploitation relations, the more “planning” is done, the greater the chaos. And to denote the magnification of the oppositions and difficulties as an “element of conscious planning” can only occur to a person who has remained stuck in the bourgeois ideology. And it is also only on the basis of this bourgeois ideology that attempts can be made to answer the question of the intellectualist rule of tomorrow with examples from the past. What was possible in feudal China and in the Paraguay of the 18th century does not and cannot demonstrate the future possibility for the intellectuals of setting up their neo-feudal rule notwithstanding the existence of the industrial proletariat.
Even though it may be “simply amazing” for Nomad to hear that in our conception the intellectuals have no economic functions, his amazement originates from his incapacity to distinguish between economic factors and those of a technico-organizational character. The capitalistic functions which his intellectuals have taken over or will take over from the capitalists are not appraised as economic. Of course, the bourgeoisie frequently employs the concept of economy even with reference to the culinary skill of their housewives; however, when we speak of economic functions, we use the word ‘economic’ in the sense of social, and do not mean the capacity to operate a factory or to manage a business establishment. Neither the capitalists nor the intellectuals fulfill economic functions; the thing is simply impossible, for under capitalism, the economy is regulated by way of the market, and otherwise it would not be capitalism. The natural necessity of bringing human consumption into such harmony with production that the society can continue to exist–and this constitutes the economy—is not consciously directed under capitalism, but takes the round-about course of the market, in which the process operates blindly.
Nomad’s argument that the fascists are to be regarded as “major partners” of Capital for the very reason that they “are swallowing up an ever growing share of the Nation’s wealth” is perhaps sufficiently disposed of with a mere reference to the fact that all countries, inclusive of the non-fascist ones, need an ever growing share of the surplus value for governmental purposes. And this is explained by the fact that, with the concentration of capital, the functions of the governments become more and more extensive and the imperialist character of capital makes necessary an ever more imposing array of instruments of power, as well as the fact that the general chaos, which is constantly growing greater by reason of the crisis, places ever greater demands upon the governing machinery, – and all this quite apart from the problems of the fascist movement.
Nor can Nomad’s reference to the “anti-capitalist gestures” of the italian fascists be accepted as proof of the correctness of his ideas, for these “social—political” factors are not at all “anti-capitalist”, but are capitalist necessities. That is to say, that these wage-increases and shorter hours are needed by Capital, so long as the thing is objectively possible, and are introduced for the most various reasons: for example, in order still further to break the competitive capacity of the small capitals in the interest of the large concerns, or in order to offset the increased intensity of the labor process and to enable the necessary reproduction of labor power, and likewise in the interest of social security, since an industrial proletariat can simply not, in the long run, be treated like slaves or serfs. This social policy is not out of harmony with the fact of the sharpened exploitation of the workers; it is rather a manifestation of this latter, revealing that Capital has been successful in raising the degree of exploitation. So that in spite of the fascist “social policy”, the situation of the italian workers has not been improved, but worsened, while italian capital has increased its profits in accordance with this worsening. Any objective work on the italian development since Mussolini’s seizure of power will teach Nomad that he talks nonsense when he asserts that the fascists proceeded against Capital in order to further the interests of the workers and thereby to conform to their own bureaucratic necessities. In general, Nomad should be more careful about the choice of his “proofs”. It is simply impossible–to take another instance–to maintain that “the Japanese officers’ caste” (25) has independent disposal over Manchuria. A single glance at the capital investments in Manchuria would have taught him better. And even though half these capital investments are made by the japanese government itself, still the japanese government can hardly be claimed to be identical with Nomad’s fascist officers’ caste, but with japanese capital and large landed property; a circumstance that finds expression, according to Nomad himself, in the fact that his officers “are in the habit of ‘bumping off’ from time to time the most prominent representatives” of the japanese ruling class.
On page 26 Nomad attempts to identify our conception regarding fascism with that of the Stalinists. We had not, however, as Nomad will have it, asserted that fascism has been created by “the necessity of saving the capitalist system either from the proletarian menace or from the internal weakness.” We said rather that “it was precisely the impossibility of further capitalist concessions to the other strata of the population which compelled the capitalists to set up and support a bureaucratic dictatorship which stands at their exclusive disposal” (26). The direct control of monopoly capital over the other social strata precluded the continuance of democratic parliamentarism. Fascism directed itself not against a menacing revolution, but against the reformist activity of the labor movement within the frame-work of bourgeois democracy. From the external point of view, fascism arose from the necessity of strengthening the imperialist potentialities. The economic concentration had to be followed by the political. The middle-class movement, for which the crisis had furnished the impetus, was put to use by Capital for the purpose of breaking the reformistically organized resistance of the proletariat to its further impoverishment. True, the middle class represented in the fascist movement its specific interests; but since these are directed against the workers as well as against monopoly capital, and since accordingly a choice has to be made, it could only proceed with monopoly capital, and not against it. This situation was put to use by monopoly capital and with the aid of fascism it succeeded in creating the preconditions for a further relatively frictionless impoverishment of the proletariat and at the same time in greatly furthering the imperialist potentialities without resistance on the part of the workers. A part of the middle class received the positions of the ousted labor bureaucracy, whereby also the solidarity of interests of the middle class was broken. With the aid of this new bureaucracy monopoly capital now controls all the other social groups. Just as previously the labor bureaucracy had to turn against the interests of its partisans, so also the fascist bureaucracy has to turn against its middle-class partisans; for the interests of monopoly capital cannot be impaired without bringing into question the whole of exploitation society. The role which is played in present-day capitalist society by the large capitals is too considerable for their existence to be brought into question. To speak of present-day fascism as an intellectualist rule is rank nonsense.
Fascism is the dictatorship of Capital in the industrial countries under the economic crisis. One cannot denominate as fascism any dictatorship without distinction. When Nomad says that fascist dictatorships rule even in “more or less undeveloped Balkan or Latin-American” countries, he fails to consider that the relatively recent concept of Fascism has a quite determinate meaning and cannot be used for dictatorship generally. The czarist dictatorship was Czarism, and it does not occur to anyone to speak of the “Czar’s Fascism”. Hence when we speak of Fascism, we mean not something general, but something definite; we mean the dictatorship of Capital in contrast to capitalist democracy. Confusion of concepts, of which Nomad makes use, can hardly take the place of proofs.
We are glad to take notice that Nomad finds his previous characterization of the intellectualist rule– “state capitalism”, “state socialism” or “capitalism without capitalists”–to be inadequate and now wants to replace these terms with that of “unequalitarian socialism”. (27) It appears, that is, that he has meanwhile arrived with Henryk Grossmann (28) at the view that “capitalism no longer exists where there is only one owner, and the Russian State, that is, the bureaucracy, is only one sole firm, so to speak.” Whatever Nomad or others may understand by Socialism or Communism, however much they may water and falsify concepts, so far as we ourselves are concerned, Communism still remains a state of affairs in which the workers themselves are the masters of the means of production, and State Capitalism the social condition in which the State stands over against the workers as the owner of the means of production just as the private capitalists did previously. That is simple and clear and needs no new formations. — But to come to Grossmann, whom Nomad likes to flaunt before our eyes.
We are not interested in Grossmann’s sympathies for the U.S.S.R., since, with all respect for Grossmann’s scientific achievement, we have still not ceased to think independently. As a matter of fact, however, what Nomad here presents as Grossmann’s view, and which he then accepts as his own, proves either that Nomad can’t read or that he is incapable of reproducing things as they are written down. Neither in the passage adduced by Nomad nor anywhere else does Grossmann say what Nomad here tries to impute to him. Grossmann does not concern himself in the least with the question of whether the hilferdingian “general cartel” is still capitalistic or already socialistic as being “only one sole firm”, since to Grossmann this “general cartel” is quite inconceivable except as “a series of cartels of separate branches of production which exchange their products among each other”, (Grossmann, Das Akkumulations-und Zusammenbruchsgesetz des kapitalistischen Systems, page 606). He says instead, in the passage adduced by Nomad: “Only one or the other is possible: either we have in the general cartel a ‘regulated’ economy, which then ceases to be capitalistic; or if it is capitalistic, then it cannot possibly be ‘regulated’. For Hilferding involves himself in an inescapable logical contradiction when he quite eliminates exchange and nevertheless still speak of a ‘capitalist’ mode of production.” (Ib., page 610.) So that what Grossmann is here concerned with is not Nomad’s question, whether “capitalism no longer exists where there is only one owner,” but whether capitalism can exist without the exchange relation. And to Grossmann, as to us, the significance of the exchange relation is represented in the following passage: “The abolition of exchange means, at the same time, the abolition of wage labor. The capitalist mode of production resting on wage labor presupposes, surely, the existence of the capital relation, that is, a relation in which labor power as a commodity is purchased on the market by the owners of the means of production. Where a commodity is exchanged on the market between the working class and the employing class, there must necessarily exist also exchange value. If Hilferding speaks of the disappearance of commodity exchange and of value–and he has to do so in order to arrive at his ‘regulated’ economy–then there is also no place for the exchange of the commodity ‘labor power’; or in other words, this implies that the capital relation also, the capitalist mode of production, must necessarily disappear. What comes to take its place may be either an unveiled master-and-man relationship, as in the Middle Ages, or else a socialist communal economy.” (Ib., page 611.) Since wage labor prevails in Russia, there must also be in existence there, according to Grossmann, a capital relation. And, thus, with the existence of the wage and capital relation in Russia, a regulated economy there is out of the question. So that to us and to Marxism the russian “planned-economy” tendencies have nothing in common with a socialist planned economy, but are only the technico-organizational measures of monopoly Capital carried to the extreme.
Nomad’s false interpretation of Henryk Grossmann is matched by his exposition of marxist principles, in which connection he rejoices that others also (Stalin, Sorel, Hook) have found it necessary to stand Marx on his head. In the first place, we may say that socialism does not mean “primarily a change in the form of production, or in the ownership of the means of production” (29), as Nomad asserts, but signifies, according to Marx and also to us, the abolition of any and all property relation with respect to the means of production thru their socialization. The question of distribution is not for Marxism “a secondary matter”, (29) as Nomad puts it, but is inseparably bound up with the form of production. With the change in the forms of production there change also the forms of distribution; nothing else in this respect is possible. Marx was not of the opinion, as Nomad writes, that “during the first phase of communism. . . there would be no equality of incomes”, but Marx writes that by reason of the equal incomes the inequality will still continue to exist. Let us listen to Marx himself: “What we have to deal with here is a communist society, not as if it had developed on a basis of its own, but on the contrary as it emerges from capitalist society… The individual producer received back from society, with deductions, exactly what he gives. What he has given to society is his individual amount of labor. For example, the social working day consists of the sum of the individual hours of work. He receives from society a voucher that he has contributed such and such quantity of work (after deductions from his work for the common fund) and draws thru this voucher on the social storehouse as much of the means of consumption as the same quantity of work costs. The same amount of work which he has given to society in one form, he receives back in another. Here obviously the same principle prevails as that which regulates the exchange of commodities, so far as this exchange is of equal values, i.e. equal quantities of labor in one form are exchanged for equal quantities of labor in another form. The right of the producers is proportional to the amount of labor they contribute; the equality consists in the fact that everything is measured by an equal measure, labor, . . . and labor, to serve as a measure, must be defined by its duration or intensity; otherwise it ceases to be a standard measure. This equal right is an unequal right for unequal work; it tacitly recognizes unequal individual endowment, and thus capacities for production, as natural privileges. Right can by its very nature only consist in the application of an equal standard, but unequal individuals are only measurable by an equal standard insofar as they can be brought under an equal observation, be regarded from one definite aspect only, e.g. in the case under review, they must be considered only as workers and nothing more be seen in them, everything else being ignored. Further, one worker is married, another single, one has more children than another, and so on. Given an equal capacity for labor and thence an equal share in the funds for social consumption, the one will in practice receive more than the other, the one will be richer than the other, and so forth. To avoid all these inconveniences right must be unequal instead of being equal. But these deficiencies are unavoidable in the first phase of communist society.” (Marx, Critique of the Gotha Program, pages 29-31).
So that Marx says exactly the opposite of what Nomad, like others previously, would like to read from him. For the very reason that the incomes are the same, whereas the individual conditions of the different workers are dissimilar, it is nonsense to speak of the removal of all inequality. Any other equality than that of incomes cannot exist in this phase of communism, as otherwise the “application of an equal standard” would be precluded, which in this first phase of communism is still necessary. Nor do the disquisitions in the Critique of the Gotha Program stand alone in this respect, but in the closest relation with the general standpoint of Marxism. Our interpretation, not that of Nomad, is confirmed by a great number of passages of “Capital”, of Engels’ “anti-Duehring”, etc. No other than our interpretation can be brought into harmony with the marxian doctrine of value. In Marx’s writings, the higher is distinguished from the lower phase of communism precisely in virtue of the fact that in this higher phase the principle “from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs” can be actualized, whereby it becomes possible to dispense with the narrow legal standpoint of equal incomes in spite of the unequal conditions of the individuals. While in the first phase of communism each worker receives for the same labor time, assuming equal intensity of labor (in case of relatively harder labor, shorter hours), the same income, since he is regarded only as a worker and nothing else, later on any standard of this sort is dispensed with, since society is able to leave this narrow legal foundation. If Nomad had made himself a bit more familiar with the communist laws of production, he would have been in a position to arrive at a better understanding of Marx’s disquisitions and he might also have spared himself the silly question “Who is to determine a man’s needs?” Nomad is incapable of conceiving an independent human being. It might be stated, however, that even if people lack the capacity for anything further, there can after all hardly be any doubt that they are in a position to “determine their needs”; at any rate, we have never yet met anyone who did not know what he wanted.
Nomad does not limit himself, however, to turning the views of other people upside down; he is also not averse to distorting reality itself in conformity with his own ideas. In order to controvert our view that even in the alleged “planned economy” of state capitalism no improvement of the situation of the working class is possible,—that here also the capitalist tendency to crisis, even though modified, continues to exist—he asserts: “Even that one per cent of planned economy which was instituted by the New Dealers has undoubtedly improved the situation of large sections of the working class and won the sympathies of the masses for President Roosevelt”. (30) In the first place, it is not permissible here to speak vaguely of “large sections” and perhaps attempt to maintain one’s thesis with a reference to the shabby “public works” of the Roosevelt Administration, since of course we constantly speak of the working class as a whole; and secondly, what is Nomad’s proof for his bold assertion? A single glance at the statistics would have shown him how badly he is mistaken. He would see that since the installation of the Roosevelt regime, the share of the workers in the social product has become not larger, but smaller; that the situation of the workers has been worsened, notwithstanding the slight upturn of quite recent date, which is not even attributable to Roosevelt’s one-percent “planned economy”, but to the inflation and the further rationalization, insofar as it is not bound up with the temporary spurt in production as a natural result of many years of depression.
The April 1936 official figures of the general business indexes published by the Federal Reserve authorities show that the volume of industrial production was 12 percent below the normal level[3]. The value of all construction contracts was 58 percent below normal, while that of residential contracts was 74 percent below normal. Factory employment in April 1936 was on this same basis 25 percent below normal, while factory payrolls were 31 percent under normal, and department store sales 28 percent below. Ponder this: The volume of industrial production is 12 percent, factory employment 25 percent, and factory payrolls 31 percent below normal. In view of the differences between these three figures, Nomad’s talk of the improvement of conditions as a result of Roosevelt’s one-percent “planned economy” is revealed as nonsense. The circumstance that the masses nevertheless stand enthusiastically behind Roosevelt is not to be wondered at, for the government and the bourgeois propaganda machine are, of course, on hand for the purpose of making those masses tipsy. The mass is enthusiastic not because it has obtained something, but because it is expecting something. In consideration of its own weakness, it sets its hopes upon a messiah. The mass enthusiasm for Roosevelt or Hitler springs, like its need of religion, not from its well-being, but from its misery.
Perhaps in order to show that the “intellectualist economy” is capable of improving the situation of the workers and hence also capable of assuring its rule for an unlimited time, Nomad will also present us with the rising wage figures of Russia. In case he does, we should like to ask him not to content himself, like the russian intellectuals, with the wage figures alone, but also to let us have at the same time the price changes. Further still, the figures regarding the development of the productivity of labor… With all these figures in mind, he himself cannot help noting that in spite of the rising russian wages, the situation of the workers has worsened with increasing accumulation. For the past year it has already become necessary in Russia to impoverish the working population not only relatively to the mounting production, but also absolutely; the disproportion between prices and wages has already led to an actual wage cut, a matter which Nomad probably knows as well as we.
Now that we have seen how Nomad can expound texts in his own interest and represent reality as he would like to have it in order not to upset his theory, it will not be surprising to hear that he can also predict in accordance with these theories our own future. Our position on the question of the intellectuals, he writes, is determined by the fact that “criticism of the intelligentsia as the ruling class of the coming period of a socialized form of economy” is directed also against our own “ambitions for power”. (31) And then he compares us with all the other groups which at one time or another have promised to serve the masses and nevertheless were only aiming at power for themselves. When we speak of Workers’ Councils, Nomad sees nothing more than the propagandists of the council idea, not the councils themselves, of which he can form no other idea than the one which he has of the bourgeois leader-mass organizations. He knows nothing at all of the economic functions of the councils, but sees in them only another party. For this reason he fails to realize how ridiculous he makes himself in referring to the russian soviets as an indication of our own future. The russian soviets were not “holding out the promise of ‘withering away’ of the State”, as Nomad imagines (32). The soviets and the bolshevist state apparatus stood over against each other as separate organizations from the very beginning of the russian revolution, the state apparatus seeing in the soviets only an instrument for the carrying out of its resolutions. With the extension of the state apparatus and the concentration of all power in the hands of the bureaucracy, the soviets were dismantled, until today they have declined to nothing more than an empty decoration of no more significance than Hitler’s “Labor Front”. It was the State, i.e. the Party, that promised to “wither away”; the soviets could promise nothing of the sort. Even though the State was able to come into existence only by means of the soviets, i.e. of the russian revolution, still under the russian conditions the bureaucracy was soon in a position to deprive the soviets of all power. To us the councils or soviets are not instruments of the revolution with which the party works, but they are the basis of the dictatorship as well as of communist production. They cannot “wither away”, nor have they any state beside themselves which could do likewise. They cannot promise that their “State” will vanish, for there is here no longer a State in the sense of the bourgeoisie or of the Bolsheviks. Their own state functions, i.e. the suppression of all capitalist forces, become superfluous with the success of that endeavor and thereby vanish. But the councils as the organization of the communist economy remain in existence. There is no special State by the side of them.
Taking as his text the brief presentation of our conception of communist society contained in one number of the Council Correspondence, Nomad tries to demonstrate that we merely use other names in promising and aiming at the same thing as all previous labor organizations. The fact simply is that as a special group we promise nothing at all: to us the revolution and what comes after it is an affair of the class, which can promise nothing to itself. It can at most do something, or omit doing something. As a part of the working class, we are pleased to cooperate in the class tasks, and it goes without saying that in this connection we will try to put across the conception for which we stand. However, our attitude is such as to preclude the possibility that we ourselves, as a special group, should occupy or strive for positions by the side of the class organizations. To that end we would first have to change our attitude and become a party. It would be only by way of the backward development to a party that we could be placed in a position to add another to the already existing labor bureaucracies. We hold it to be impossible henceforth, under the present conditions in the industrial countries, to develop a labor bureaucracy which would be able to operate against the class interests of the proletariat. The period of capitalist dictatorship preceding the revolutionary uprising precludes the forming of organizations which would be capable of holding the revolution to certain paths in conformity with their desires. Whether in the process of the revolution itself, organizations will be formed by which the previously forming councils will again be destroyed is very questionable, even if not precluded. Still, just because this possibility exists, it is all the more necessary to insist on the exclusive rule of the councils. If reactionary forces should succeed in emasculating the councils, it is thereby also precluded that the workers’ situation would be improved. The revolution is in that case only temporarily brought to a standstill; it will have to arise anew. In the last instance, the councils must after all assert themselves, for they alone are capable of actualizing communism, and only this latter is capable of doing justice to the needs of the masses.
According to Nomad, however, even then nothing is yet attained; for as he sees it, the councils will then do the same thing as the state capitalist parties attempted previously. And he tries to prove it to us with our own words. Since we speak of the necessity of centralism he writes that this “necessary centralism actually does away with the means of production in the hands of the producers,….is nothing but our good old Bolshevik State bureaucracy”. (33) It would lead too far to explain to Nomad at this place the process of communist economy. It might be stated here, however, that there are all sorts of centralism, and not centralism without qualification. The technico-centralistic management of large industrial concerns is something different from the capitalistic centralization of power in the hands of a few capitalists. The authority of the technico-organizational central apparatus extends only to the technico-organizational matters of the concern; it is subject to the control of the actual owners of these concerns. The technico-organizational and the economico-political centralization may, as in Russia, be largely combined; here the planning commission operates in harmony with the government, or carries out its desires. Not every centralism, however, signifies actual power over society. Whether the central control of production and distribution is at the same time centralization of power, or only a technical function and nothing more, depends on the whole complex of social conditions. A central planning commission alone has no power over the producers; in order to have that, it has to have also at its disposal material means for putting thru its plans even against the producers’ will. That is to say that in order to impose its own will, it must have by the side of itself a state apparatus. It is not the central planning commission in Russia which can exercise dictatorship, but only the State with its police, soldiery, etc. Without this special state apparatus, not subject to the control of the producers, the centralization of economic activity is void of all authority; it can fulfill only technical functions, no economico-political ones. When there is no special State beside the councils, when the armed enterprises represent the one and only actual social power, then the central organization itself is reduced to a mere enterprise, to a clearing house, of no greater importance than any other enterprise. Nomad’s incapacity to distinguish between technical and economic matters trips him up in his consideration of communism quite as fatally as before in his consideration of the functions of the intellectuals under capitalism. Incidentally, it might be stated that Nomad need not lose any sleep over the fate of the unemployed. It is not at all the bureaucracy that “will have to tackle the problem of reorganizing the industries”. (33) As previously, so also under communism, industry can be reorganized only by industry itself. The enterprises are quite capable of taking on workers; they are in no need, to that end, of the orders of Nomad’s intellectuals, who ordinarily know as much about the enterprises as a tapeworm does about sunlight.
And now a word regarding that “very suspicious passage”; namely, our statement that “equality must not only be actually possible; it must also be capable of driving forward the productive forces of society”. That was by no means intended “artfully” with a view to later justification of inequality on the ground of the unripeness of the situation. Of course, we too are aware that between theory and practice a complete agreement is not always immediately possible and that the organization of the communist society also will be faced with great difficulties; yet for that very reason, the theory must be represented all the more consistently. Whether communism, as we see it, will be actually capable of complete realization “on the morrow after the revolution” is a question which we pass over as idle speculation. We know that any reorganization of society is a long and painful process; but we know also that this process can only be shortened when one takes part in it as if the “morrow after the revolution” were going to find the complete communism in operation. The more consistently the revolutionists proceed, the greater the success. Just as today we adjust our policy to the overthrow of Capital, altho Capital is still sitting tight in the saddle, so also we have adjusted our policy to the immediate complete realization of communism, without regard for the fact that the process will probably be a tedious struggle. However, when we said that “equality must also be capable of driving forward the productive forces of society”, what we had in mind was nothing of the sort that Nomad terms “suspicious”. On the contrary: since we are convinced that even today in the industrially developed countries only equality, communism, is capable of driving forward the productive forces, we wished here to give expression to the idea that in such countries only communist revolutions are possible. Marx welcomed the development of capitalism as a development of the social forces of production and this development was bound up with the existence of classes, was the horribly bloody process of the creation of the proletariat and of industry. No equality was here possible; equality would not have been able to develop the productive forces in the measure in which capitalism was able to do so. The development of the productive forces at a certain stage of the development of human society is bound up with inequality. Inequality is here progressive. Equality in backward Russia, for example, with but little industry and an infinitesimal minority of proletarians, would never have been able to develop the productive forces in such measure as has been possible under the inequality of the bolshevist-capitalist dictatorship. The Bolshevists, like Capital in other countries, were progressive because they promoted not equality but inequality, even though by reason of this they became a reactionary force with respect to the international revolution. An exploiting society is objectively revolutionary when this exploitation is identical with the development of the productive forces. It is not until it stands in the way of the development of those productive forces that it becomes objectively reactionary. To renounce the exploitation of the russian workers would be for Russia objectively reactionary; the inequality and exploitation has called forth industry and produced the proletariat, forces which today announce the coming in Russia of the communist revolution. Our point of departure is constantly the industrial proletariat in countries where the bourgeoisie is compelled to restrict the productive forces. Only such a proletariat, in such countries, is in a position, by means of communist equality, to drive forward the productive forces.
When we further said that with the setting aside of the class relations “there vanish also the sharp distinctions in the evaluation of the various labor functions”, we meant exactly what we said; not what Nomad tries hard to understand by it, “that there will be different income levels, but that these differences will not be very sharp” (34). The sharp distinctions in the evaluation of the various labor functions vanish precisely because of the equal incomes. An engineer will not feel so far removed from a manual worker when both have the same incomes; for it is not so much the occupation by which people are separated, but the various incomes to which those occupations give rise.
We do not regard it as possible to convince Nomad of what any other serious work on the subject would tell him, namely, that there has unmistakably been bound up with the development of the productive forces a leveling up of the intelligence of the various social strata, and that with the further development of the productive forces this process is bound to go on, the one being inseparable from the other. The intelligence of the workers is not dissociated from society even when their activity is restricted to the performance of a manipulation, since the decisive thing here is not the manipulation but the state of society as a whole. Such things, which are understandable forthwith to any reflecting human being, we do not consider it possible to make clear to Nomad because his conviction of proletarian helotism is too hidebound to be shaken. “Ninety-nine out of a hundred (workers),” he writes (36), “understand absolutely nothing of the complicated business of running a highly involved social system of the machine age,”; without the faintest suspicion that he is here merely giving expression to his own incapacity. When we assert that the working class is in a position, without and if necessary against the intellectuals, to conduct their society, Nomad sees nothing more than shabby demagogy which flatters the workers in order to win them.
The workers, according to Nomad, are incapable of anything, but he finds that society can be conducted very well by Heinz Neumann’s “Lumpenproletarians” and the “similar group of declasse intellectuals and semi-intellectuals who seized all the power in Russia” (27). What the workers can not do, altho they are practically the masters of all production, that can be done quite well, according to Nomad, by the “outs”, “the unemployed or underpaid journalists, lecturers, college graduates and under-graduates, lawyers without clients and doctors without patients, educated ex-workers in search of a white collar position,” etc., etc. (18). And accordingly Nomad’s struggle against this intellectual rabble cannot be taken seriously. For if the workers themselves are not in a position to take over production today, they will not be capable of doing so tomorrow either; if the intellectuals have or obtain a monopoly on the control and direction of production, they will also know how to make this monopoly permanent. That, however, could only be welcomed, according to Nomad’s theory, since the intellectuals have become a blessing to the workers: without them the workers would have to go hungry, since they themselves are, of course, incapable of directing production. And so the workers would be obliged, in their own interest, to further the ambitions of the intellectuals, instead of turning against them, for the existence and the success of the intellectuals is the condition precedent to their own existence and their own success. What Heinz Neumann still spoke of as the “Lumpenproletariat” has meanwhile become for Nomad the light of humanity. True it is only in their own interest that the intellectuals are the workers’ benefactors, since they make use of the workers in the struggle against the old capitalists; but still their success is in line with the workers’ most immediate interests, since they must offer the workers more than these latter receive from the private capitalists. So that Nomad is then quite consistent in saying that it is very much a matter of indifference which of the existing labor organizations the workers join, since “each of these organizations, in its endeavor to win the workers, is bound to help them in obtaining higher wages, shorter hours, etc.” (41). And since, according to Nomad, this is and must be done also by the Fascists, we really fail to see why they too should not be favored with working-class support.
In all this, Nomad never once stops to ask himself whether what he asserts is in harmony with the facts or, if so, is permanently possible. As a matter of fact, political parties and trade unions have long assured their existence by helping to make possible any improvement in the workers’ situation. It is solely for this reason, of course, that the history of the old labor movement has become a history of labor fakery. The fact that these organizations, just like the whole of bourgeois society, of which they are a part, have had to be both revolutionary and reactionary, helpful to the workers at one time and injurious at another—this temporal factor Nomad has quite overlooked. In reality, it is only in quite determinate historical conditions that these organizations are able to “do something for the workers”, while under other historical conditions they are obliged to operate against the workers’ interests, whether they want to or not. What Nomad has to demonstrate is that these organizations are today in a position to become the workers’ “benefactors”; but that is simply not demonstrable.
But to come back to the assertion that the intellectuals are capable while the workers are not, of directing production. In the first place, here again we meet with the confusion of technical with economic matters. For as yet the intellectuals have performed no social-economic functions; they still leave these to the market, not only in private-capitalist countries but also, in a somewhat more organized form, in Russia. And as concerns their technical functions, Nomad attaches to them excessive importance. If he had but a faint idea of modern enterprises, or if he could see the modern industrial proletariat as it actually is, it would become clear to him that this proletariat is quite in a position to manage production. This management is also a function to which may be applied the statement which Nomad relates exclusively to ordinary manual tasks; it “can be learned in a few days or weeks” (35). Incidentally, the greater part of the present-day intellectual functions is not devoted to production, but to activities which are necessary only in a profit economy, while in a communist society they drop out.
Furthermore, of course, it is not at all necessary that the workers themselves perform all indispensable intellectual functions forthwith. All that is necessary is that they have charge of the enterprises, for thereby they have control also over the intellectuals. Enterprises are not mastered with intellectuals, but with arms. They are mastered thru economic measures which preclude the arising of special organs of power by the side of the workers’ councils. They are mastered also by reason of the fact of our constituting the majority, which counts when it is not opposed by any special political apparatus of power. With the mastery of the workers over the enterprises and thereby over production and distribution, nothing remains to the intellectuals but to place themselves at the disposition of the working population. They are obliged to take their places in the economic system determined by the workers, or they have to go hungry. Who, then, would continue to doubt that a part of the intellectuals necessary for production, in early recognition of the consequences of the altered situation, will take their places willingly in the new order, and thereby isolate and render still more powerless the part whose attitude toward this order is still unsympathetic. Under communist conditions, the intellectuals will no more be in a position to exist outside society than they are today. If they want to live, they have no choice but to work together with the workers in the enterprises.
We have here been obliged to speak from the standpoint of Nomad’s argumentation, altho it would have been much simpler and more enlightening to deal with this problem without regard to Nomad, from the standpoint of Marxism. Only a further word in conclusion: Just as there is no theory, however false, which does not contain also a grain of truth, so also Nomad’s theory is based upon a partial truth. Since class oppositions exist under capitalism and state capitalism, and since the intellectual professions are for the most part exercised by elements of the middle class, the opposition between middle class and proletariat, between middle class and capital is manifested also as an opposition between intellectuals and workers, or intellectuals and capitalists. From one of a number of phases of these class oppositions, Nomad constructs the eternal opposition between intellectual and manual activity. History ceases to be a history of class struggles; it becomes a struggle between the educated and those on the way to becoming so for the mastery over the ignorant; a state of affairs to which Nomad applies the name of permanent revolution. Yet, in this competitive struggle between the educated or relatively educated, the ignorant also are continually gaining, since in order to get the support of these latter the competing group is obliged to have more to offer them than has the intellectual element in power at the time. Thus the salvation of humanity lies in this competitive struggle of the intellectuals, and thus things will slowly become better also for the less educated, so that they themselves will naturally become more and more enlightened. And all that in complete independence of the economic problems of society and its transformations. If, however, we think Nomad’s theory of the “permanent revolution” consistently to its end, we can come to no other conclusion than that here also, where the situation of the workers keeps on improving, a point must of necessity be reached at which equality is established and the opposition between intellectuals and workers has wholly disappeared; and hence there disappears also Nomad’s permanent revolution, which now, after all, like all other socialist theories, has its “final”. But even tho Nomad himself may like to split his head over the question of how he arrived at a permanent revolution without permanency, our attention continues to be directed to the more important problems of the class struggle between Capital and Labor.
—P.M.—
[1] “The Masters of Tomorrow”, Council Correspondence, Sept. 1936, to which, unless otherwise states, all page numbers (in parentheses) refer.
[2] It is interesting to note that in Nomad’s article in Scribner’s, the socialist leadership was not to be had for Bismarck’s plans ostensibly because in the state capitalism conceived by Bismarck all the good positions “would go to the educated scions of the Junkers, and the upper middle classes”; while in Nomad’s biography of John Most, Lassalle wants to proceed with Bismarck against the “upper middle class.” Now if Bismarck’s state capitalism was directed against the “upper middle class”, how can Marx and associates then occupy an unfavorable position toward Bismarck’s plans on the ground that their carrying out would have brought all the good positions to the elements of the “upper middle classes”?
[3] The general business indexes are stated in terms which take their averages for the years 1923–25 as being equal to 100.